Frameworks

Core framework

Virtue Ethics

Be the kind of person who acts well.

Guiding principle

Right action is what a person of practical wisdom, exercising the virtues, would characteristically do in the situation.

Key thinkers

Aristotle · Alasdair MacIntyre · Philippa Foot

Strengths

  • Attends to character, motive, and context, not just discrete acts.
  • Explains why the same act by different agents can differ morally.
  • Integrates emotion and perception into ethical judgment.

Common objections

  • Circular: virtuous acts are what the virtuous do, who are recognized by virtuous acts.
  • Culturally variable lists of virtues.
  • Under-determinate in genuine dilemmas.

Mini-example

A whistleblower asks not 'what maximizes utility?' but 'would a person of courage and justice stay silent here?'